
When you hear “erga magnetic separators,” the first thing that comes to mind for many is something very powerful and universal, almost a magic box that will sort everything itself. In fact, if you dig deeper, you understand that the key here is precisely ?erga? — we are talking about separators with manual or, more precisely, with ore-dismounting cleaning. And this is where the nuances begin, which are often kept silent in catalogs, but become a headache on the shop floor. I went through this myself more than once.
In theory it's simple:erga magnetic separators- these are devices where the magnetic system is stationary, and the working elements, those same “ergs” or plates, require periodic manual cleaning of the magnetic product. Sounds archaic? Maybe. But in certain technological chains, especially when it comes to large-piece material or when a very pure magnetic fraction without overgrinding is required, there are few alternatives to them.
A common mistake is to consider them outdated and slow. Yes, performance is lower compared to self-cleaning models, that’s a fact. But where it is not the tonnage per hour that is important, but the quality of separation or the specifics of the material (say, high humidity, which “clogs” automatic cleaning systems), they turn out to be indispensable. I remember that at one of the old mining and processing plants they tried to replace the battery of such separators with modern machines - in the end they returned to the old ones, because the losses of magnetite in the tailings increased by almost a percent, and this is a lot of money.
Another point that suppliers rarely talk about is the qualifications of personnel.Erga magnetic separatordoesn't work on its own. Its effectiveness directly depends on the operator, who must feel the material, understand when exactly it is necessary to stop the feed and carry out cleaning. It's not a button, it's almost a craft. And if this understanding is not there, even the most expensive device turns into a piece of hardware.
Working with equipment of different brands, I also came across Chinese manufacturers. Here, for example,LONGI Corporation(official website -https://www.ljmagnet.ru). The company, which, as indicated in their materials, was created back in 1993 and has grown into a large manufacturer of mining equipment. They also have erga separators in their assortment. What can I say from my own experience? Structurally, they are often quite solid, especially for their price categories. But there is a nuance.
Their equipment, like many others, is designed for certain average technological regulations. And in life, as you know, there are no ideal conditions. We once installed their separator at the site for the additional enrichment of iron ore concentrate. According to the passport, everything is fine. In practice, it turned out that the design of the non-magnetic fraction unloading unit does not cope very well with the material of our specific size and flowability. Local skilled mechanics had to “finish it with a file” — install additional vibrators. The equipment itself was generally normal, but without such adjustments its efficiency would have been noticeably lower.
This, by the way, is a common story. Anymagnetic separator, especially the erga type, is not a ready-made solution, but a basis for it. It always needs to be “grinded in”. to a specific factory, to a specific ore. Those who buy, load into the car and expect a miracle are usually disappointed. We need a competent commissioning operator, or better yet, a technologist who understands the process.
So in what cases should you look towards this seemingly not the most progressive technology? From personal experience I can highlight several scenarios. The first is small or pilot installations, where the volumes are small and the cost of full automation does not pay off. The second is working with valuable minerals, where every lost grain is a loss, and visual control of the operator during the cleaning process is critical.
We had a project involving the extraction of wolframite. We used separators with manual cleaning. Automation was absolutely not suitable - thin films and splices in the material required very careful, almost jewelry-like removal from the drum. The operator literally “combed” magnetic product with a special scraper. Productivity, of course, was not so hot, but extraction increased so much that all economic calculations justified it.
The third scenario is harsh conditions. Dust, moisture, vibration. Sometimes simple and maintainable designerg magnetic separatorturns out to be more reliable than a sophisticated device with a bunch of sensors and servos. There is almost nothing to break there. It can be repaired using welding and a sledgehammer, which in a remote quarry is the main criterion.
If we talk about the market, then this segment is quite specific. Large Western brands have not focused on such machines for a long time; they have moved towards highly automated lines. The niche is occupied by manufacturers from the CIS countries and, of course, China. Here we return toLONGI. Their plant, according to information, has an area of 140,000 m2 and a staff of more than 1,200 people. The numbers are impressive. This is not a workshop, but a full-fledged production. The annual production of 4,000 units of equipment indicates a serious scale.
What does this mean in practice? As a rule, large factories have a more streamlined quality control system for casting and assembly of magnetic systems. And this is the main thing in separators. An uneven magnetic field or faulty poles will negate all the work. Their products are usually in order in this regard. But, again, there is a “but?”. Their documentation and calculation tables are often far from the reality of our fields. You have to recalculate and check everything yourself, on the spot.
Colleagues from other companies sometimes complain about the long delivery of spare parts. Although, if you work through official distributors, rather than trying to buy directly from a factory in China, the process goes faster. The main thing is to immediately place an increased warehouse stock of key components when ordering: the same erg plates, linings, bearing units.
Is it worth developing this direction? Or is this a dead end branch? I think that it has its own nicheerga magnetic separatorswill stay for a long time. Yes, the world is moving towards digitalization and full automation. But there are too many variables in mineral beneficiation that are difficult to fit into an algorithm. Human experience, the eye, the ability to quickly make a decision based on incomplete data - so far this will not replace any sensor.
Perhaps the future lies in hybrid solutions. For example, the basic process is carried out automatically, but at critical control points or for final finishing, the principle of manual cleaning is used under the supervision of an operator through a visualization system. Something similar is already appearing in the form of prototypes.
In the meantime, when choosing such a separator, you need to clearly understand: you are not just buying a unit, you are buying part of a technological chain that will require attention, adaptation and competent hands. And if you realize this, thenerga magnetic separatorscease to be a “relic of the past”, but become simply the right tool for a specific task. Like a hammer or wrench - simple, but indispensable in your business.